all Service

Review

Review

To ensure that APCJ publishes only the highest quality papers and that all material submitted to the journal is judged in an objective and fair manner.

A book review should be preceded by following information.

1. The book being reviewed :
Author(s) or Editor(s) of work
Date of Publication
Tilte of work (Complete)
Publisher, Location
ISBN number
Number of pages
2. Reviewers
Recommendations of reviewers from the basis for the Editorial Committee’s decision whether to publish the paper.
The Editorial Committee of ETRI Journal selects three reviewers for their knowledge and experience of the paper’s topic.
Reviews should be returned within the requested or agreed upon time frame, usually 4 weeks for regular papers and 2 weeks for Letters.
The Review system is double – blind : the reviewers’ identities are not disclosed to the authors, nor are the authors’ identities disclosed to the reviewers.
Reviewers use the ETRI Journal standard from for their evaluation and recommendations
3.Review
Begin with a brief paragraph containing an overview of the book and its purpose. Discuss the author’s qualifications if pertinent.
Review the book chapter by chapter or in other units of your choice. In any event, write short paragraphs and separate units by subheadings to assist the reader.
Discuss the strengths and weaknesses of the work as well as elements that could be improves, eliminated, or expanded.
Write in a positive tone rather than a negative tone.
End with a summary of the major aspects of the work, with a concluding statement as to whether the work achieved its purposes. Conclude by suggesting where or how the work can be used best.
4. General Guideline
Use specific, concrete terms rather than general or abstract works.
Avoid clichés.
Be succinct in word usage as well as sentence and paragraph construction.
Do not include footnotes in the review.
If sources are cited, incorporate the reference into the review.
5. Length of review
A range of 1000-2000 words is preferred.
  • �̿���
  • �������� ��޹�ħ
  • ��� �� ȯ�ұ���
Institute of APEC Collaborative Education (IACE) 63beon-gil 2, Busandaehak-ro, Geumjeong-gu, Busan, 46241 Republic of Korea
Bussiness lisence no. 621-82-06068
Tel: (+82) 51-515-7617 Fax : (+82) 51-515-2617